← Team building

A Retention Strategy Dressed Up as Kindness

You didn't sign up to be liked. You signed up to do the job, and to do it well.

A few days after we hired a new warehouse employee, mistakes started showing up on our live website. We asked around. Nobody fessed up, and the mistakes kept happening. My business partner built a small program just to track changes, and once we finally got it working, we found the culprit: our new warehouse hire. He had no idea he was changing the website at all.

My co-founder and I were frustrated, and we both wanted to let him go. Our sales manager came to his defense instead. "Let me try him in sales," he said. "Give me one month."

We were skeptical. This was someone struggling with software we'd built ourselves and took real pride in, and in that moment we couldn't see that it might genuinely be hard to use for someone without our technical background. But he was kind, the mistakes were clearly accidental, and none of it had caused lasting harm. One month, I agreed.

He stayed five years, in sales.

Ask what they'd win in, not what you're losing

That's the whole idea in one story. He wanted to be there and loved working for the company. The passion was never the question. The skill for that particular job wasn't there yet. I didn't have a bad employee. I had one who wasn't in a position where he could succeed yet.

Call it what it actually is: a retention strategy dressed up as kindness. Replacing someone costs you a job posting, weeks of interviews, and months of ramp-up before they're even as good as the person you let go. Repositioning someone who already knows your product, your customers, and your systems costs you a conversation and a little patience.

The same move turned an overwhelmed generalist on my customer service team into someone promoted specifically to review and coach other agents' conversations: a narrower, lower-burnout role that used everything she'd learned without asking her to keep doing the part that was wearing her down.

When the cut is real, cut with care

Sometimes repositioning isn't an option. Layoffs, a shutdown, a pivot that means a role just doesn't exist anymore. When you know you have to cut, cut quickly, and focus on what you're keeping, not what you're losing.

But "help them land somewhere" shouldn't be a nice line. Make it an actual practice:

  • When we cut remote support agents for cost, not performance, I went looking for other companies with open remote roles and made the introductions myself.
  • When a longtime agent was leaving for the same reason, her manager wrote her a strong reference letter, unprompted, before her last day.
  • When the cut could be hours instead of people, we took it there first and reduced warehouse hours company-wide instead of removing individuals.

Put the recommendation letter in the offboarding

Build it into the process instead of leaving it to memory. When you're cutting for cost or because a department no longer makes sense, not for performance, write the recommendation letter and include it in that person's offboarding documents. Do the same for anyone who gives notice and is someone you'd genuinely recommend.

Never fire someone for giving notice

If an employee gives you two weeks' notice, do not terminate them on the spot. If there's a real security risk or their attitude is actively damaging the team, let them go that day if you have to, but pay out the two weeks regardless.

Your existing team already knows how you treat people on the way out. Leaving on good terms, and letting people go as fairly and kindly as possible, are surprisingly effective retention tactics in disguise.

It gets better, not easier

The first time I ever had to fire someone, I cried while doing it. It was more than a little embarrassing, but at least they knew I felt the weight of it. The last time I let someone go, I got a handshake and a sincere thank-you.

That's the actual measure: not whether it ever stops being hard, but what it looks like on the other side of the table once you've learned to do it with care.

And one harder truth. I once wrote to a former employee, years later: "If I was a better manager at the time, I would have simply told you your career path needed to take you elsewhere." I'd kept them longer than I should have because they were good and I didn't want to lose them. Sometimes the kind thing is telling someone it's time to spread their wings.

Before your next termination conversation

  • Ask: is there a role this person could actually win in?
  • If the cut is for cost, write the recommendation letter first.
  • Make two introductions to companies that are hiring.
  • If they gave notice, pay the two weeks no matter what.
  • Remember your team is watching how you handle this.

Follow me on Instagram: @darbycox

Want help building your own team? Book a call with me.

Dealing with this in your own business?

Book a 30-minute chat and get a straight answer from someone who's been there.